New Orleans' Historic Carousel Bar: A French Quarter Landmark

Is a dimly lit, historic watering hole in the heart of the French Quarter truly the oldest bar in the United States? Lafitte's Blacksmith Shop, a New Orleans institution, whispers tales of pirates, smugglers, and a history that predates the very nation it resides in, sparking a debate that continues to this day.

The allure of Lafitte's Blacksmith Shop lies not only in its potential claim to the title of oldest bar, but also in the rich tapestry of legends woven around it. The building at 937-41 Bourbon Street is steeped in mystique, its weathered brick exterior and flickering gas lamps hinting at centuries of secrets. The popular narrative paints a picture of the Lafitte brothers, Jean and Pierre, infamous privateers, utilizing the building as a blacksmith shop by day and a clandestine operation for fencing their illicit goods by night. Underground tunnels, allegedly connecting the shop to the nearby river, provided a convenient means of transporting their ill-gotten gains, adding an extra layer of intrigue to the bar's already captivating story. While the exact origins and functions of the building remain subject to historical debate, the atmosphere it creates is indisputable.

The bar's claim to antiquity is often repeated in New Orleans, where it's a standard stop for many tourists, however, the title of oldest bar in America is not without its contenders, and the discussion often brings about passionate opinions. One common challenge to Lafitte's primacy involves the White Horse Tavern, which, while opening later, has seen continuous operation since 1957. The title is bandied about in conversations and tour guides, although the exact details often vary and depend on the definition of oldest - some would state that the oldest means the original building, regardless of the operation; others would argue that “oldest” refers to the continuity of business, while others may focus on the age of the structure itself.

The structure itself is believed to have been built in the 1770s, during the Spanish colonial period, making it one of the oldest surviving buildings in the city. This history, alongside the colorful narratives associated with the Lafitte brothers, forms the foundation of the bar's identity and enduring appeal. While its exact age and the specifics of its early use are debated, the fact remains that Lafitte's Blacksmith Shop predates the United States, tying the bar to a time when New Orleans was a different city, shaped by various colonial powers and the vibrant, often lawless, spirit of the frontier.

The bar's enduring popularity is testament to its atmosphere and unique appeal. Lafitte's, with its dimly lit interior, the glow of gas lamps, and the weight of history, offers a refuge from the lively Bourbon Street crowds. Unlike some of the more boisterous establishments nearby, Lafitte's offers a more subdued atmosphere. It still attracts a throng of visitors, eager to soak up the ambiance, but in a more subdued way, in accordance with the bar’s long history. For some, the bar's history is more compelling than the drinks, while for others, the bar's selection of beverages complements the historical experience.

The French Quarter itself is a historic district, full of bars and other historic sites. While many bars in the Quarter are historic in their own right, Lafitte's stands out due to its physical structure and legends. The area is known for its distinctive architecture, historic buildings, and the ongoing preservation of the cultural heritage of the city, and Lafitte's fits right in. The bar contributes to the rich tapestry of the French Quarter and the larger historical allure of New Orleans, making it a popular stop for both tourists and locals.

Other bars, such as the Napoleon House, also hold a strong position in New Orleans' bar scene. Owned and operated by the Impastato family since 1914 and Ralph Brennan since May of 2015, it's a place that suspends. While the age and history of the building are undeniable, and the quality of the bar’s atmosphere is undeniable, it may not be able to compare to the historical and alleged importance of Lafitte’s Blacksmith Shop. Napoleon House is also a popular destination, however, Lafitte's is a key stop for many tourists exploring the city's oldest establishments.

The oldest bar title, as seen across the United States, is often fiercely contested. The White Horse Tavern in Newport, Rhode Island, a strong contender, opened in 1673, and has a claim to this particular distinction. It's a debate that underscores the allure of history and the desire to connect with the past. It's a matter of perspective, with each bar offering its unique blend of history, ambiance, and local culture. Lafitte's, even if it doesn't hold the absolute title, offers a unique experience, tied to the city's past.

Many other bars are listed in Top 10 Best Oldest Bar in New Orleans, LA lists, yet none quite have the historic recognition of Lafitte’s. Old Absinthe House, The Carousel Bar & Lounge, and Pat O'Brien’s are just some of the establishments that have gained recognition among the city's oldest bars. Each has its distinct atmosphere, its share of tales, and its following of patrons. Some, like the Chart Room, are more local haunts. These bars, alongside Lafitte's, collectively showcase the rich bar scene of the city.

The bar remains a key element in the city's identity. Its legacy, whether as the oldest bar in America or not, is firmly established. It is a place where locals and tourists alike come to experience a taste of New Orleans' past, enjoying a drink amid the ambiance, and perhaps, pondering the countless tales whispered by the walls of this historic landmark. The allure of its mysterious history remains a defining feature of the bar. This ongoing appeal ensures that Lafitte's Blacksmith Shop will continue to be a cornerstone of the French Quarter, a reminder of a city rich in culture, legends, and the enduring spirit of the past.